top of page
Search

Tol'dot, 5787 - He is Edom

7 days ago
2 min read

As I’ve mentioned now a few times, this year I’m writing about Genesis from the perspective of myths and origin stories. In our Torah portion this week, we have a pretty crucial origin story… presented to us in just five words. At the beginning of the story of our third patriarch, Jacob, we immediately see a tense rivalry with his twin brother, Esau. Even in the womb - we are told - the two of them battled for primacy. In the first story about the two brothers interacting, Esau is famished after being out hunting game and doing manly things. He asks Jacob for some of the “red-red stuff” (Gen. 25:30), likely stew, that he was making, and the text tells us, “thus he was named Edom” (v. 30), which comes from the Hebrew word for “red,” “Adom.” That wasn’t actually his name, of course, but supposedly that was why he was known as Edom, and indeed he becomes the father of the Edomite people. 



To our ancient ancestors across generation after generation, and even to this day, the identity or the actual history of the Edomites is irrelevant.  This moment in Genesis of linking Esau to Edom became a pivotal origin story. These people are our rivals, our enemies, and they have been so since the earliest days of our shared story. More than a millennium after this episode is meant to have taken place, yet still two thousand years ago, our rabbinic forbearers heaped insult upon insult upon Esau in their Biblical commentaries. Why? Because Edom - the red people - represented the evil, oppressive (red) Roman Empire. It would be lethal to slander the Roman rulers directly, so they railed against the terrible Esau instead. Pouring out our rage on the sinister Edomites became a euphemism throughout the ages for an enemy we couldn’t publicly criticize on pain of death. 



Still today, you can hear someone refer to Hamas or Hezbollah as Edomites or Esau, because the analogy still works. Though perhaps this time it isn’t so much that we’re afraid of their retribution; bitterly we must admit that their violence comes no matter what we say. Instead, calling our modern-day foes “Esau” is a way of saying we’ve been in this fight for millennia. The faces may change and the motivations for war shift, yet the origin story remains the same. The two brothers in Genesis do interact a few more times, usually with tension and distrust. Yet in the end, they do come back together to bury their father, Isaac (Gen. 35:29). Can that final chapter of their story mean the door to peace hasn’t fully shut? Maybe not today, maybe not in our lifetime, but perhaps some day these two warring peoples will find peace. It feels unimaginable today, but that doesn’t mean it can never happen. The road to peace is out there. Some day, please God, our descendants will emulate their ancient ancestors and bury their troubled past… together. 


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page